Crime & Scandals

Crypto Casino BC.Game Caught with Algorithmic Bias in Video Poker and Baccarat by ProvablyFair

An investigation has found that BC.Game's video poker games gave players lower returns than advertised. The casino has acknowledged the problem, taken the affected games offline and announced more than $1.9 million in compensation.

Share

Crypto Casino BC.Game Caught with Algorithmic Bias in Video Poker and Baccarat by ProvablyFair img

Crypto casino BC.Game, which recently signed several new ambassadors, used a card-shuffling algorithm that gave players lower returns than its advertised RTP, an investigation by independent auditing organisation ProvablyFair.org has found. The audit found that video poker returned less than BC.Game advertised. CEO Ali Muhannad responded on X and confirmed that single-player baccarat had the same problem. He also announced more than $1.9 million in compensation for affected players.

What ProvablyFair's Tests Revealed About BC.Game's Video Poker RTP

ProvablyFair.org started by testing 62 video poker hands, with 0.1 USDT on each. The team checked the results with BC.Game's fairness verifier. Then the researchers ran a simulation of 600 million hands, using the game's paytable and optimal strategy.

The results showed an RTP of 96.4%, while BC.Game advertised 98%. The casino's house edge was actually 3.6%, not 2%. For every $1,000 wagered, players could expect to lose around $16 more.

Older versions had the same problem. The game advertised at 99% RTP actually returned around 97.3%. Another version promised 96% but delivered only 94.5%.

BC.Game's shuffle had a flaw. Cards next to each other in the fixed deck had almost identical values. The system changed each value by one character instead of generating random ones. As a result, these cards appeared together 1.3 times more often than expected.

This also meant fewer winning combinations for players. The simulation showed 19.1% fewer royal flushes, 13.6% fewer straight flushes and 13% fewer flushes than expected.

The verifier's approval did not mean the game was free from this problem. Every one of the 62 hands received a passing result, despite the underlying bias in the shuffle. The checks established a match between the cards and the supplied seeds, but offered no confirmation that the dealing process was statistically fair. The verifier checked whether the cards corresponded to the supplied seeds, not whether the shuffling process was unbiased.

The public verifier provided another clue. Its fixed card list had not changed since April 2020. However, the dealing method documented in the game produced no matches when the researchers tried to recreate their 62 test hands.

BC.Game CEO Acknowledges Shuffling Issue and Announces More Than $1.9M in Compensation

Following the publication of the findings, BC.Game CEO Ali Muhannad responded in a post on X. In his statement, he acknowledged that the same flaw had affected both video poker and single-player baccarat. BC.Game has now suspended the two games temporarily as its team works on a replacement algorithm.

Muhannad explained that the problem stemmed from changes made to the original deck order in 2020. The casino had developed the algorithm in 2018, but the changes made two years later introduced an unintended bias that went unnoticed by the team.

The CEO also confirmed that affected players would receive bonuses worth more than $1.9 million combined. These bonuses will come without wagering requirements. BC.Game identified the following groups of affected accounts:

  • Video poker: 576,782 accounts, with approximately $1.78 million in compensation.

  • Single-player baccarat: 142,267 accounts, with around $137,000 in compensation.

As for the replacement, BC.Game intends to develop a new shuffling algorithm based on the mechanics of bingo draws. Muhannad has not announced when the new system will be introduced.

ProvablyFair has called on the casino to replace the faulty algorithm, publish information about the periods during which each version of the games was in use and reimburse players for their additional losses.

The investigation, however, does not establish that BC.Game deliberately introduced the bias.


Share

No spam, just News. Straight to your Inbox.

Join to stay up to date on your states gambling news and offers.


Mykhailiuta Maryna img
Mykhailiuta Maryna

Game Analyst & Reviewer

Mykhailiuta Maryna Game Analyst & Reviewer

More news